The Bridgewood
Gardens Hosta Book

Chapter

Plantain Lily and the
Slug Bait Episode

 
 
Growing Hostas
Why We Grow Hostas
Where Hostas Grow
Growing in the South
Planning Hosta Gardens
Watering
Fertilizing
Dividing
Fall Planting
Winter Losses
Hostas in Containers
Problems
 

Choosing Hostas
How Big Will They Get
Hostas for Sunny Areas
Green Hostas
Gold Hostas
Blue Hostas
White-Centered Hostas
Tetraploid Hostas
Fragrant Hostas
Streaked Hostas
Hosta Flowers

Plantain Lily and the Great Slug Bait Episode
A cautionary tale about using slug bait and other chemicals in the garden

The Big Move
In 2003 we moved our nursery from Maryland to Virginia. If you would like to see the story, click here.  It seems funnier now than it did at the time.












 


























 

 

 


This is Plantain Lily.  Obviously we call her Lily.  Lily was given to me as a birthday present in 1998, and on the same day I got her, I damn near accidentally killed her. And this is the gripping story about why I hate slug poisons that contain metaldehyde (which includes the vast majority of slug baits).

And let me state from the beginning, I do not know who gave her the beer.  I do not condone giving beer to dogs less than 3 years old.

On her first day with us, her first day with me as her guardian and protector, I had to go to a  friend's nursery so I took her along to show her off.  And since I don't use slug bait, it didn't occur to me that this awful stuff would be scattered throughout the hostas. Until I looked down and saw her eating something.  "What's that blue stuff?" I asked.  "Uh, slug bait." came the reply.  And off we went, flying down the road to the nearest vet, driving 60 miles an hour through suburban Baltimore, running red lights and terrifying pedestrians.

At the vet's office, they gave her something that made her puke her guts out.  Everything came up bright blue and you could see the little pieces of bait pellets that she had eaten.  They called Poison Control and the word came back that Lily had consumed a lethal dose, but the fact that we got it out so fast was encouraging and she might live.  At least that made me feel a lot better about having run down three innocent children on the way to the vet.  Her first night as my dog was spent at the vet's, hooked up to intravenous anti-convulsives. 

The next day, the vet told us that it looked like she would be alright, that if she was going to die it usually happened within 24 hours, but that sometimes dogs appeared to recover but died 2 or 3 days later.  That was sort of encouraging.

Well, happily Lily lived with no ill effects.  For a while we wondered if her ears were ever going to stop growing, and we thought about naming her Mule Ears, but eventually she caught up with them.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And that's why I hate slug bait.

 


Since I posted this page I've had a couple of people opine that I have overstated the danger. Apparently, some manufacturers now put Bitterex in their product to make the pellets taste bad to mammals. That's a good thing, but unfortunately, I haven't found slug bait for sale in our area that lists Bitterex on the label.

Click here to see what the National Pesticide Information Center has to say.

Based on information supplied by our friend Bill Myer (see article here), we are informed that supposedly "safe" slug baits, containing iron phosphate, such as Sluggo and Safers, might be even more dangerous to dogs, children and other wildlife than traditional metaldehyde baits.

These chemicals can be used safely, by placing them where only slugs can reach them, but that involves some thought.  Spreading the pellets through the garden by the handful is not the answer.